Cameron Freeman | 416-533-6024

Internet Strategist, Managerial Anthropologist, Archivist

Menu
  • About Cameron R. Freeman
  • Socio-Cultural Anthropology
    • The Applied Anthropology Group
    • Anthropology of Culture
      • Population Control and the Colonization of Women’s Bodies in a Neo-Liberal World
      • Marketing Feminine Hygiene in a Capitalist Consumer Driven Society
      • Israeli Personhood and the Politics of Reproductive Technologies
      • The cultural biography of the Verner’s Pattern prismatic compass
      • Kinship, Kin Cues and the Fulfillment of Institutional Aims
    • Anthropology of Religion: General
      • Anthropology of Indigenous Peoples
      • A Comparison of Schleiermacher’s Inner Religious Sanctuary and the External Domain of Robert Orsi’s Religious World
      • Religion: The promise of an afterlife
      • Spiritual Interventions: Inside A.A.’s Fundamentalist Healing Program of Faith With Works
    • Medical Anthropology
      • Book Review: Reproducing Jews: A Cultural Account of Assisted Conception in Israel by Susan Kahn
      • Illness Narratives and the Construction of Self and Healing
      • Collaborative partnering with traditional healers for improved access to ARVs in rural Malawi
      • Ayurvedic Ethics and Modern Medical Ethics
    • Anthropology of Religion: Hindu Tradition
      • Constructing and Deconstructing the Bonds of Modern Guruship in the Cult of Sai Baba
      • Maintaining the Guru’s Hegemonic Influence Over Devotees
      • Christianity in British Colonial India and the Crystallization of Modern Hindu Religious Identities
      • The Dynamics of Bhakti in the Guru-Shishya Relationship
      • A Film Critique of Robert Gardner’s Video Ethnography: Forest of Bliss
      • To Love Siva is to Know Siva: Reflections on Ciruttontar—the Little Devotee
    • Anthropology of Religion: Asian Traditions
      • A Precis of Thomas A Wilson’s Sacrifice and the Imperial Cult of Confucius
      • A working definition of the Chinese term ‘wuwei’ (nonaction, doing nothing)
      • Chinese Popular Religion
      • Shang Divination: A Theocratic Stage for Emerging Chinese Religious Thought and Practice
    • Anthropology of Indigenous Peoples
      • Settler Colonialism and Eliminating the Native
      • Identity, Social Invisibility, Institutional Structures of Violence and the Mortality of Aboriginal Women
      • Define or be defined: Constructing indigenous identities for health and well being
      • Recovering Native Identities: From a traumatic ruptured past to a locally driven pan-Native spiritual present for holistic health and well being
      • The Legacy of Colonial Intrusions and Native Women’s Health
    • Anthropology of Religion: Judeo-Christian Tradition
      • Scribes, Prophets, & Temple Priests: The process of establishing and maintaining Judean boundaries through the canonization of scripture.
      • Honour and Shame and the Qualifications of the Overseer (bishop) in Timothy 3:1-7
      • The successful transmission of Paul’s expectations for a centrifugal missionary tradition in the early Christian Church
      • A hypothesis for the original oral version of the Parable of the Sower
      • Jesus and First Century Jewish Purity Laws
      • Who were the post-Wycliffe Lollards, what did they practice and what became of their movement?
      • Holiness Snake-handling: A Context for Pentecostal Epistemology
  • Principia Discordia
    • Contemporary Archaeology
      • WW1 Verners pattern MKVII military marching compass
      • Antique gramophone lovers beware of crap-o-phones and franken-phones
      • Come into my parlor for afternoon tea and listen to my “authentic” Victor Victrola
    • Confessions of A Cult Leader: My Lifestream Seminar Experience
      • Confessions of a Cult Leader or How I learned to get the best of life running a personal development seminar company.
      • Confessions of A Cult Leader: Thursday Evening of the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • Confessions of A Cult Leader: Friday Evening of the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • Confessions of A Cult Leader: Saturday Morning of the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • Confessions of A Cult Leader: Saturday Afternoon of the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • Confessions of A Cult Leader: Saturday Evening of the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • Confessions of A Cult Leader: Sunday of the Lifestream Basic
      • Excerpt: The pit: a group encounter defiled, by Gene Church and Conrad DCarnes. (Out of Print)
      • Courage
      • Please Hear What I’m NOT Saying
      • Love is NOT enough! – A Handout at the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • The girl I used to know – A Handout at the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • The Penalty of Leadership – A Handout at the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • The Little Boy who put the world back together: A story by Jim Quinn, Founder of the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • Clarifying questions – Asked throughout the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • Guiseppe – A story by Jim Quinn, Founder of the Lifestream Basic Seminar
      • Mexican Crabs – A story by Jim Quinn, Founder of the Lifestream Basic Seminar
    • Charles Haanel: The Master Key System
      • Part One: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Two: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Three: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Four: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Five: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Six: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Seven: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Eight: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Nine: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Ten: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Eleven: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Twelve: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Thirteen: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Fourteen: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Fifteen: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Sixteen: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Seventeen: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Eighteen: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Nineteen: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Twenty: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Twenty-One: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Twenty-Two: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Twenty-Three: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
      • Part Twenty-Four: The Master Key System by Charles Haanel
  • Presentations
    • Rules For Results
    • Media Skills Training
      • Case Study: Guerrilla tactics for maximizing the results of your media campaign
    • Keynote & Workshop Accolades
Menu

Define or be defined: Constructing indigenous identities for health and well being

As an underlying government strategy to assimilate and civilize Natives, the tactics of alcohol regulation has been, and continues to be used as an instrument to shape the myth of the “drunken Indian” as part of the social imaginary, and thus provides a civilizing discourse that can be used to effectively mask overt assimilation strategies, deflect attention from the real causes of social unrest and dysfunction in many Aboriginal communities, and justify bureaucratic surveillance and interventions into the lives of Indigenous peoples of Canada.

From a Settler-colonial perspective, Aboriginal peoples of Canada are like “primitive children” needing government control and regulation. Furthermore, Aboriginals present Canadian bureaucrats with a two-front “Indian problem” (Tait 2000:199). First, Aboriginal resistance to assimilation and modernization underscored by protests by First Nations, Inuit and Métis groups over loss of land, resources and collective autonomy with calls for justice, apologies, compensation and self-determination provokes a great deal of animosity by non-Aboriginal to the “Indian problem.”  Secondly, a plethora of social issues and health problems inundating many Aboriginal communities generates uncomfortable attention on the role of Canadian colonialism in causing the “Indian problem” and underlines benefits to the state in framing itself as a moral intervenor (Tait 2000:199).

Since the Indian Act of 1868, liquor control was used to police boundaries and assert racial ideology that forced Indigenous peoples into marginalized social and cultural niches (Thompson & Genosko 2009). Moreover, the legal classification of “Indian” tied to an Interdiction List, which would later become known as the “Indian list”, would mediate pejorative perceptions and conceptualizations of First Nation peoples. Furthermore, Interdiction legislation would produce a legal description of “Indian”, which would be used in court cases within Canadian law to describe “Indian” as having a particular susceptibility to, and likely to be injured by, the use of liquor or intoxicants (Thompson & Genosko 2009).

Ironically, there is no evidence that suggests that Native peoples have a genetic propensity towards alcohol abuse. In fact, the phenomena of alcohol abuse is more linked to poor economic conditions, and when alleviated, the outcome is a decrease in alcohol abuse (Thompson & Genosko 2009). However, there is evidence to show that Interdiction legislation not only constructs the stereotype of the “Drunken Indian”, it is responsible for constructing the social conditions, which facilitated alcohol abuse by Aboriginals. For example, the prohibition of alcohol on the reserves made it illegal for Natives to drink in their own homes, so, forced to go into town, they would spend their money on drinking binges, and being highly inebriated with no means of getting home, they would loiter drunk in the streets of Kenora, thus perpetuating the “Drunken Indian” myth (Maxwell 2011: 1). Furthermore, settler anxieties are exacerbated by drunken Native behaviour producing racist attitudes by the local police which lead to the incarceration of a disproportionate number of Indigenous people for liquor offenses, thus criminalizing the Native and further reinforcing the myth of Aboriginals as a drunken, criminal, vagrant, and an irresponsible people (Maxwell 2011: 4). This racist, discriminatory stereotype could then be used to explain why Aboriginal communities are so dysfunctional, with a myriad of social issues and health problems. Moreover, this constructed notion of the “drunken Indian” as a determinant in Native dysfunctionalism, strategically deflects attention from the broader picture of intrusive colonial practices that have disrupted Indigenous lifestyles and threatened livelihoods, including land dispossession, residential schools, restrictions on trapping, hunting and fishing, industrial pollution and the growth of the welfare state (Maxwell 2011:3).

Settler society views health and social problems as the cause of economic problems. In this discourse, dominant society avoids blame for the structural violence it imposes on marginalized peoples—putting the onus upon the individual (Tait 2009:199). In the 1980s, a widely held belief, propagated by the media and government policy makers and health researchers, suggested the majority of Aboriginal women were subjecting their fetuses to dangerous levels of alcohol and other drug substances, which lead to the construction of fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS). Although there was no real evidence-based science to support FAS, replacing the “civilizing the Native” discourse with a more potent and politically-palatable medical explanation could be used as scientific leverage to explain a host of Aboriginal problems, including criminal behaviour, drug and alcohol abuse, school dropout and the proliferation of teen pregnancies. Furthermore, this constructed identity of sick and dysfunctional Aboriginal communities could be used to show how the Native is unable to cope with modern Euro-Canadian living and justify further colonial intrusions under the guise of identification, prevention and treatment/intervention (Tait 2009: 199).

In order to defend Native culture from further subjugation, I posit, to circumvent the hegemonic discourses of non-Indigenous culture, Aboriginal identity must reframe itself from both a local and national context. Achieving a successful Indigenous self-determined society will require the credibility of doctorate-trained Native psychologists and applied medical anthropologists, who are recognized by the dominant society.  Natives with academic credentials can assert greater power to assist their communities by providing effective bridging between Canadian Governments services, conceptualizing culturally appropriate economic, social and health programs and services adapted for Native experiences, legitimizing Native organizational structures, and serving as creative administrators, program developers, local researchers and clinical supervisors (Gone 2009:435).

Bibliography:

Gone, Joseph P. (2009). “Encountering Professional Psychology: Re-Envisioning Mental Health Services for Native North America.” Healing Traditions. The Mental Health of Aboriginal Peoples in Canada. Vancouver & Toronto: UBC Press 419-439.

Maxwell, K. (2011). Ojibwe Activism, Harm Reduction and Healing in 1970s Kenora, Ontario: a Micro-history of Canadian Settler Colonialism and Urban Indigenous Resistance. Comparative Programme on Health and Society Working Paper Series.

Tait, Caroline (2009) Disruptions in Nature, Disruptions in Society: Aboriginal Peoples of Canada and the “Making” of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. Healing Traditions. The Mental Health of Aboriginal Peoples in Canada. Vancouver & Toronto: UBC Press 196-218

Thompson, S., & Genosko, G. (2009) LCBO and First Nations People in Punched drunk : alcohol, surveillance, and the L.C.B.O., 1927-75 Black Point, N.S.: Fernwood Publishers.

Search

US Customers – Invoice Payments

US Customers - Invoice Payments
On submit this form will redirect to my paypal account.
© 2023 Cameron Freeman | 416-533-6024 | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme